Question about welded wire from FastTech, NR-R-NR?

Status
Not open for further replies.

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,342
1
83,932
So-Cal
fasttech regularly has lacking descriptions. I'm just reasoning here, but it's more likely that FT has an incomplete description than it not being the most common wire used in vaping. Of course, I don't know for sure, and I'm no expert in metallurgy so I couldn't even start to guess what the practical differences between FeCrAl and FeCr would be.

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk

I think I am starting to Lean Heavily that this Wire is Kanthal after reading this...

An[d] what do you suppose vendors will start calling their "Kanthal" once they get hit with the cease and desist en masse?

Kanthal - Kantian - FeCrAl

And perhaps FT Intentionally omitted the "Al".
 

AzPlumber

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 28, 2011
5,051
9,789
Arizona
Still twist mine. Guess I'm a diehard. Still love my oddy's and term-c's. Seen those welders at times and thought it would be nice but always a day late or dollar short lol.
All the nr - r - nr wire I have purchased from fasttech has been kanthal for what its worth.

Sent from my LGL63BL using Tapatalk

Yes, a diehard if your still building an Ody, I applaud your tenacity.
 

Gahh

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 24, 2013
678
946
Bay Shore LI NY
It's like you said earlier, without knowing the % of anything, who knows how well it really works. I don't know how much of a difference the lack of Al will/would make (if it doesn't actually have any in it) other than increased wear rate, possibly. I guess having or lacking a certain amount of Al could affect the resistance per length amount, but I'd imagine it'd be minimal.

EDIT: Just a thought but if it isn't for temp use, wouldn't the mod just kick over to power mode?
I don't think any TC mods have any way of determining what any coil is made from.!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: stols001

KenD

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Aug 20, 2013
5,396
9,257
47
Stockholm, Sweden
kennetgranholm.com
I don't think any TC mods have any way of determining what any coil is made from.!!!!
They will identify a tc capable coil by noting a rise in resistance as the coil heats up, and many mods will kick you out of tc if the resistance doesn't increase (or if it doesn't increase fast enough - here's the root of the problem many wismec mods have with complex coils in tc. The wire mass is so large that it takes a long time for the coil to heat up, and thus the mod doesn't register a fast enough increase in resistance and kicks you into power mode).

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk
 
  • Agree
Reactions: stols001

papergoblin

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 16, 2013
973
2,246
alabama
I don't think any TC mods have any way of determining what any coil is made from.!!!!

Sorry, took the night off, lol. My Steam-R Mini, will kick out of temp, want to say some some older mods I had did too. Can't remember and sold all the VW's I had other than this mini, as I mainly stick to mechs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stols001

Gahh

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 24, 2013
678
946
Bay Shore LI NY
They will identify a tc capable coil by noting a rise in resistance as the coil heats up, and many mods will kick you out of tc if the resistance doesn't increase (or if it doesn't increase fast enough - here's the root of the problem many wismec mods have with complex coils in tc. The wire mass is so large that it takes a long time for the coil to heat up, and thus the mod doesn't register a fast enough increase in resistance and kicks you into power mode).

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk
I do not have much knowledge about how TC mods work.
But if a TC mod kicks out of TC mode, and just goes into power mode on its own, this can't be a good thing. Especially when using Ti or Ni.
All these complex situations and problems is why I'm not a big TC fan.
My real concern with my original posting is if the NR-R-NR wires, which are Ni200 - ( ?Kanthal ? ) - Ni200 , can this be used in power mode safely.
As there is 8 wraps around 3.5mm jig and ( 2 wraps on each end of the coil are Ni200 ).
Thus when powering up, the 4 wraps of Kanthal are the primary heating element of the coil, but there is the 4 wraps of Ni200 which are the makeup of this coil.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stols001

440BB

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 19, 2011
9,222
33,992
The Motor City
I do not have much knowledge about how TC mods work.
But if a TC mod kicks out of TC mode, and just goes into power mode on its own, this can't be a good thing. Especially when using Ti or Ni.
All these complex situations and problems is why I'm not a big TC fan.
My real concern with my original posting is if the NR-R-NR wires, which are Ni200 - ( ?Kanthal ? ) - Ni200 , can this be used in power mode safely.
As there is 8 wraps around 3.5mm jig and ( 2 wraps on each end of the coil are Ni200 ).
Thus when powering up, the 4 wraps of Kanthal are the primary heating element of the coil, but there is the 4 wraps of Ni200 which are the makeup of this coil.

I would think it is best to find a premade wire with enough length of resistance wire to make the entire coil you want, with the welded joints just beyond the coil ends. I hope somebody else has more experience to clarify that, as I buy mine precoiled at fairly high resistance.
 

Gahh

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 24, 2013
678
946
Bay Shore LI NY
My original post / question and all replies to it have me thinking in a whole new way.
Do we, and should we believe prebuilt coils are truly made from what they say they are.
Thought,,, if the company that makes Smok coils buy their materials from a company who mislabeled the material, WHAT DO YOU REALLY GET!!!!!!
 
  • Useful
Reactions: stols001

KenD

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Aug 20, 2013
5,396
9,257
47
Stockholm, Sweden
kennetgranholm.com
I do not have much knowledge about how TC mods work.
But if a TC mod kicks out of TC mode, and just goes into power mode on its own, this can't be a good thing. Especially when using Ti or Ni.
All these complex situations and problems is why I'm not a big TC fan.
My real concern with my original posting is if the NR-R-NR wires, which are Ni200 - ( ?Kanthal ? ) - Ni200 , can this be used in power mode safely.
As there is 8 wraps around 3.5mm jig and ( 2 wraps on each end of the coil are Ni200 ).
Thus when powering up, the 4 wraps of Kanthal are the primary heating element of the coil, but there is the 4 wraps of Ni200 which are the makeup of this coil.
NR-R-NR wire is great for coil heads that hold the leads in place with a rubber grommit. You won't risk burning the grommit as the NR part of the wire won't heat up (much).

As for a tc mod kicking you out of tc mode. Mods that do that usually kick you into a low wattage setting. It is to indicate clearly that you're not using a tc capable wire, or that there's something else wrong. Otherwise the mod would just fire at the full set wattage without limiting temperature and you'd be at a much greater risk of burning the wick.

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk
 

papergoblin

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 16, 2013
973
2,246
alabama
NR-R-NR wire is great for coil heads that hold the leads in place with a rubber grommit. You won't risk burning the grommit as the NR part of the wire won't heat up (much).

As for a tc mod kicking you out of tc mode. Mods that do that usually kick you into a low wattage setting. It is to indicate clearly that you're not using a tc capable wire, or that there's something else wrong. Otherwise the mod would just fire at the full set wattage without limiting temperature and you'd be at a much greater risk of burning the wick.

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk

Exactly, but if, like with this wire, it'd be about the only way to know if it is temp or power wire.

EDIT: Just thought about it, technically this wire could be used either way. As is it should work in power mode (watts). Clip off both NR legs and use center, still power mode, use either of the NR legs only and should work in temp mode.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stols001

Coastal Cowboy

This aggression will not stand, man!
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 13, 2013
5,972
21,934
61
Alabama Gulf Coast
www.ibleedcrimsonred.com
They will identify a tc capable coil by noting a rise in resistance as the coil heats up, and many mods will kick you out of tc if the resistance doesn't increase (or if it doesn't increase fast enough - here's the root of the problem many wismec mods have with complex coils in tc. The wire mass is so large that it takes a long time for the coil to heat up, and thus the mod doesn't register a fast enough increase in resistance and kicks you into power mode).

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk
I think Arctic Fox fixes this. It does it on Eleaf mods, anyway. I had a monster coil in one of my tanks that took a beer commercial to ramp up and the Pico Dual with AF firmare handled it gracefully.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stols001

KenD

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Aug 20, 2013
5,396
9,257
47
Stockholm, Sweden
kennetgranholm.com
I think Arctic Fox fixes this. It does it on Eleaf mods, anyway. I had a monster coil in one of my tanks that took a beer commercial to ramp up and the Pico Dual with AF firmare handled it gracefully.
I prefer simple coils, dual twisted 28ga maximum, so I don't have problems with the Wismec firmware. I tried Arctic Fox on one of my rx200, but it wasn't for me. I actually prefer the Wismec/Eleaf/Joyetech firmware, but I'm weird in other ways as well... [emoji3]

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk
 

KenD

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Aug 20, 2013
5,396
9,257
47
Stockholm, Sweden
kennetgranholm.com
Exactly, but if, like with this wire, it'd be about the only way to know if it is temp or power wire.

EDIT: Just thought about it, technically this wire could be used either way. As is it should work in power mode (watts). Clip off both NR legs and use center, still power mode, use either of the NR legs only and should work in temp mode.
I'm quite sure that wire isn't useable in tc. The NR ends are simply there to protect the rubber grommit from burning, it won't heat up noticeably.

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk
 

papergoblin

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 16, 2013
973
2,246
alabama
I'm quite sure that wire isn't useable in tc. The NR ends are simply there to protect the rubber grommit from burning, it won't heat up noticeably.

Sent from my Thor E using Tapatalk

In a whole no, but the NR ends are ni-chrome (don't remember the abbreviation), which is a temp wire for some mods, won't say all, as I'm not a temp user. You're right about the heating up though, they pass current faster, causing the hot spot in the R part of the wire, so by the time the NR could get hot enough to melt/burn grommets, the wick has been beyond cooked in the coil.
 

AzPlumber

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 28, 2011
5,051
9,789
Arizona
In a whole no, but the NR ends are ni-chrome (don't remember the abbreviation), which is a temp wire for some mods, won't say all, as I'm not a temp user. You're right about the heating up though, they pass current faster, causing the hot spot in the R part of the wire, so by the time the NR could get hot enough to melt/burn grommets, the wick has been beyond cooked in the coil.

NiChrome is an excellent resistance wire used in a variety of applications, it doesn't change resistance much when heated and not suitable for TC.
 

papergoblin

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 16, 2013
973
2,246
alabama
NiChrome is an excellent resistance wire used in a variety of applications, it doesn't change resistance much when heated and not suitable for TC.

My bad Ni wire which is nickel-titanium not chromium, don't know why I was thinking chrome (well I do I don't do temp, lol.) I just remembered it was Ni-200 wire which will/should do temp if separated from the "Kanthal" type center.
 

mcclintock

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
  • Oct 28, 2014
    1,547
    1,787
    I do not have much knowledge about how TC mods work.
    But if a TC mod kicks out of TC mode, and just goes into power mode on its own, this can't be a good thing. Especially when using Ti or Ni.
    All these complex situations and problems is why I'm not a big TC fan.
    My real concern with my original posting is if the NR-R-NR wires, which are Ni200 - ( ?Kanthal ? ) - Ni200 , can this be used in power mode safely.
    As there is 8 wraps around 3.5mm jig and ( 2 wraps on each end of the coil are Ni200 ).
    Thus when powering up, the 4 wraps of Kanthal are the primary heating element of the coil, but there is the 4 wraps of Ni200 which are the makeup of this coil.

    That's how the Aspire vertical (chimney, actually) coil unit I took apart was made, except more like 6 wraps heating and 1.5 on each end non-heating.

    That wire can be used in power mode, and only in power mode. The resistance of the nickel is almost insignificant, especially on the higher resistance wires where the nickel is also thicker than the heating wire.

    Re: rubber grommets, when they're involved NR-R-NR is the only way to go -- even if the original manufacturer or other DIYers didn't!
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread