Looking for the best Earthy-tasting e-liquids

[MaxUT]

555 from My Freedom Smokes.

Dekang Turkish Blend in VG from Cignot
Dekang Winston in VG from Cignot

RY4 is a possibility -- most people either love it or hate it. Since you're looking for earthy, try Janty. They also have a newer version which is less sweet, RY4 X.

All of the above flavors will blend together well, so you could make interesting combinations by adding some of this, some of that to your cart or cartomizer.

 

[NBinSD]

I don't think anyone's mentioned it yet so I'll throw it out there... Johnson Creek Tennessee Cured is a really good tobacco all day vape. Great taste.. doesn't get nasty tasting after a while. I've tried about a few other tobacco flavors but didn't like'em.

I think also flavors from different companies are very different. I got a 5ml RY4 from liberty flights and loved it. Ordered a 30ml from another company and it tasted totally different.