I'd give The Vapor Chef a shot. I LOVE their tobacco juices. Their VC #13 is a cigarette like tobacco juice. Deep Thought and Slartibartfast are 2 of my favorites, followed up by Honey Nut Tobacco and Apple Bourbon Tobacco
I tried the vc menthol tobacco #13 and it had that leafy, overripe, sweet-sour tobacco flavor that I'm trying to avoid. Deep thought sounds good, but I'm afraid it has the same tobacco base? I love some of VC's fruits though, so maybe when I reorder I'll try it.