For my small dog's, I boil a large breast chicken, shred it and mix it with boiled rice. I get about a weeks worth of dinners .. During the day, he munches on Ians healthy naturals' lamb and rice (has done wonders at eliminating his joint stiffness problem it seems)..
For the cats, they are all addicted to meow mix original. I've tried to get them into better cat food brands but they just don't want them, even new kittens when they are old enough to eat will avoid their kitten food and go after the meow mix, and only the original one..weird but least they picked a brand decent priced enough I guess since we have way too many permanent kitties around
This sounds like a good idea for my Shih Tzu. She's the only one of my dogs that has a sensitive stomach.
My cat only likes Purina Naturals dry food. Like you, the premium brands don't interest him, nor do any of the wet foods I've tried. Silly cat !