Hiya Six!
Let me preface this by saying that I smoked 1-1.5 packs/day of Marlboro Red 100's for 21 years. This is such a personal preference question, expect to get a lot of varied responses.
I found that for the first week or so after picking up a PV that I stuck to a mild tobacco flavor (Marlbro.) I tried a couple of the flavors I'd ordered, but I couldn't really taste them all that well; Marlbro was at least familiar. Not straying far I think helped me stay away from the coffin nails.
After my sense of taste started to come back, I was able to appreciate the spectrum of flavors much more. I still wander back to Marlbro, but not quite as much.
I'm particularly fond of 555 (nutty) and RY4 (caramel.) My absolute favorite is a DIY mix of LorAnn's Butter Rum. I tend to hang around 16-18mg. All of my e-liquids are Holy Smoke! from
Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce
So. Here's a list of what I've tried and what appealed to me.
(18mg)
-HS! Chocolate - I like it, my wife loves it. Reminds me alot of hot chocolate.
-HS! Marlbro - Something like a cowboy killer in Medium taste.
-HS! Coffee - A little harsh on my throat, I did get a good black coffee feel.
-HS! Vanilla - not quite as strong a vanilla as I'd like, but passable.
-HS! 555 - a nutty and smooth tobacco flavor. I love it.
-HS! RY4 - a strong caramel. I love it.
(HS! 54mg unflavored mixed down to 16mg, LorAnn's flavorings)
-Butter Rum - I'm a huge butterscotch/butter rum freak. I can't get enough
-Orange Cream - a lot like inhaling a dreamsicle. More pleasant than it sounds, really
-Banana Cream - I'm not really a fan, my wife likes to mix it with HS! Chocolate
-Creme de Menthe - I wasn't really a fan of menthols during my analog days, but this is a nice and smooth mint, really opened breathing, refreshing
-Maple - Sweet Jesus. It's like huffing fresh syrup. Mix with a little vanilla and butter rum, and you've got breakfast.
-Chocolate Hazlenut - Not bad. I've been meaning to cut HS! Coffee with this
-Amaretto - Not as good as I'd hoped. It tasted like medicine. Almond medicine.
Long story short, I'd recommend samples of:
555, RY4, maybe Hilton (another tobacco flavor, but seemingly wide appeal), then depending on tastes, Chocolate and a fruit or two. Apple and Grape seem to be popular choices where Cherry has quite a few reports of having a cough-syrup taste to it.
Most importantly though, remember that your taste will fluctuate wildly for the first couple of weeks to a month. What might have been crappy the first week could turn out to be a go-to vape later.
Good luck!
-HB