Hmm, Pancake vs Stumpy? Personally, I find the Pancake to be a pretty good atty dependant on the build. As to where the Stumpy is quite versatile, the pancake is more finicky and coil positioning is everything. Get it right and it has good draw, production and flavor. Get it wrong and it heats up way too fast and gets downright hot. Titanium can get hot real quick if the coils are too close to the sides of the deck. For me the comb jig is a bit of a gimmick in that it is way to small to grasp and use effectively with my big mitts.
Here's a quick shot of the current build I'm using and it works the best that I've tried so far. Triple 2.5mm 28's to 0.4. Nice warm and wet vape without getting too hot...As always YMMV.
View attachment 540304
This build heated up like a burner on the stove...
Also built it with a single coil both horizontally and vertically in both center and side positions with pleasant results as well.
With all this being said, if it came down to one or the other, hands down it would be the Stumpy for me...