TFA Vanilla Bean Gelato Substitute?

[we87]

A new recipe I wanna try calls for vanilla bean gelato from TFA which I don't have. I'd like to try the recipe before I order just that one flavor. Anything else come close?

I have:
LA Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla
TFA French Vanilla
CAP Vanilla Custard
TFA Vanillin
CAP New York Cheesecake
TFA Vanilla Swirl
TFA Whipped Cream
TFA Bavarian Cream
TFA Vanilla Bourbon

 

[Troy Noh]

from what I understand, vanilla bean gelato is refomulated vinilla bean ice cream without the bad stuff. try using the vanilla swirl. Just caz a recipe calls for something doean't mean you have to follow it to the letter.

 

[Sgt.Rock]

I'd try Vanilla Swirl plus Whipped Cream if I had your choices...

 

[Troy Noh]

or try the Vanillia Swirl with Bavaie cream, or sweet cream

 

[we87]

Thanks for all the info. Okay so vanilla swirl it is. If I do add whipped cream or BV would yall do like a 2:1 vanilla swirl to either BC or WC?

 

[sketchness]

I personally would try the Cap french vanilla with marshmallow if you have it. the thing I get from vanilla bean gelato is the fullness it imparts.

 

[we87]

I personally would try the Cap french vanilla with marshmallow if you have it. the thing I get from vanilla bean gelato is the fullness it imparts.

Don't have that particular one